Butter Bean Soup with Portabellas and Wild Rice
In the depths of winter weather--or as deep as it gets in these parts--often the only thing standing between me and acute culinary boredom is the freezer. Sure, pumpkins and winter squash are exciting at first, but it doesn't take long before summer produce envy sets in and I start pining for the juicy tomatoes and fresh field peas of a few months ago. There's not much I can do about the tomatoes--canned and frozen are okay for cooked dishes, but they're never going to make it into one of my salads--but peas and beans that have been frozen when they're fresh lose only a little of their taste and nutrition and make a decent substitute for the fresh thing.I have friends and neighbors who buy enough butter beans and lady cream peas to eat their summertime fill and have enough left over to blanch and freeze for the winter. In my next life, I hope to be one of these people. For now, I have to settle for store-bought frozen peas, which I'm able to find in several varieties. For this delicious, savory soup, I used Pictsweet brand speckled butter beans. They're about the same size as Fordhook lima beans, but they're dark and a little less starchy. If they're not available in your area, feel free to substitute frozen lima beans or black-eyed peas. Just avoid anything canned; I find that canned butter beans can ruin the flavor of just about anything!

Butter Bean Soup with Portabellas and Wild Rice
(printer-friendly version)
If you don't have wild rice, pearled barley or another grain can be used instead; just be sure to pick one that cooks in less than an hour.
2 medium onions, diced
2 ribs celery, diced
4 cloves garlic, minced
6 cups water
1 pound speckled butter beans or Fordhook lima beans, fresh or frozen
6 ounces baby portobello mushrooms, sliced
1/4 cup wild rice
1 teaspoon thyme
1 teaspoon dried rosemary, crushed, or 2 tsp. minced fresh rosemary
1/2 teaspoon sage
1-2 teaspoons salt (to taste)
1/4 teaspoon black pepper
1 teaspoon soy sauce
Heat a large non-stick pot. Add the onions, and saute until they begin to brown, about 6 minutes. (Add a tablespoon or two of water to prevent sticking, if necessary.) Add the celery and garlic, and cook for another two minutes.
Add the water and butter beans and bring to a boil. Add all remaining ingredients, bring back to a boil, reduce heat, and simmer until the beans and wild rice are both done, 45-55 minutes. If necessary, thin soup with water as it is cooking, according to taste. Just before serving, about 1/2 cup of the beans may be mashed or blended to make the broth thicker.
Makes 6 servings. Per serving: 151 Calories (kcal); trace Total Fat; (1% calories from fat); 7g Protein; 29g Carbohydrate; 0mg Cholesterol; 849mg Sodium; 6g Fiber. Weight Watchers Core / 2 Points.
Labels: CORE, eat to live, gluten-free, Southern cooking









33 Comments:
Scrumptious!!
Looks easy and delicious! Perfect for the season :)
I could also imagine some of the water with red wine for an even heartier and flavorful base.
Oh man! Oh man! Oh man! I've got to make this soon!!! I looove butter beans and pretty much everything else in this soup =)
Beautiful! I envy your food, and your photographic skills!
Looks rich and hearty.
Making this right now!! It's simmering. Yummmy! I used frozen lima beans because I didn't find the butterbeans. Pre-sliced baby portabella mushrooms cut down prep time too! Can't wait to taste!
mmmm..this looks good. i'm going to make this for breakfast tommorrow. your recipe's are the bomb!
Oh, that looks fantastic. I can't wait to try it.
I am so impressed with all the different kinds of beans and peas you have access to, Susan. . .this looks delicious and beautiful! Thanks, and all the blessings of the winter season to you and your family :)
this looks gooood.
This soup sounds hearty, healthy and tasty!
It's summer here but I had to give this a try anyway. The only butter beans available here are canned so I used frozen broad beans. I thought they were the same as lima beans but Wikipedia tells me I'm wrong. Either way, the soup was delicious.
Mmmm.... looks like the perfect dish for winter weather! :)
I had every single one of these ingredients in my kitchen last night...so guess what I made?
It was a darn tasty soup. I bumped up the wild rice to two thirds a cup. By the time everything was almost done, the broth was still a bit too watery for my taste, so I added some extra soy sauce and some wine I had about. I'd probably start out with some vegetable stock the next time I make it, though. Definitely a keeper of a recipe.
Mary R--glad you enjoyed it.
About the watery broth, I realized after I posted this that I forgot to mention that I blended about 1/2 cup of the beans and added them back into the soup. That does help make the soup a little thicker and improves the flavor. I apologize for the omission.
Mmmm that sounds really good! I wonder if I can convince my husband to go to the store and make it for me, since I'm sick... bleh. And I didn't know the canned butter beans ruined flavors... we have some, but we also have frozen Limas!
Looks like tomorrow night's dinner! Thanks!
Sylvia
Sounds yummy and perfect for the season!
I've got dried butter beans in my pantry. Would those work as well? Should I precook or soak them first?
Can't wait to try this!
I love the inclusion of a bit of soy sauce. I've found it can be used in a surprising variety of dishes (I even use a tbsp in hummus).
Looke wonderful!
Susan, I am really not fond of lima beans or black-eyed peas (the latter you can't find in England anyway, except in international foods shoppes), and my wife loves her tinned butter beans BUT I'll look for frozen, then try this soup out after the holidaze.Serendipitously, I've asked to make my famous wild rice & mushroom casserole (which also has celery & almonds) for either Xmas dinner, or dinner the next day.And stupid me didn't have mushrooms on *my* shopping list (I blame her as divvied up the chores...)
Imaginary states: Yes, cook the beans first. Actually, any cooked beans will work here, or you can use a cup of uncooked lentils and make it a lentil soup.
Veggie Guy: I love using just a touch of soy sauce to give a sauce or broth a little depth. Never thought to try it in hummus, though!
That soup is the perfect thing to eat on a cold rainy day. It looks delicious!
Mmmm butter beans. I don't know why but I just love 'em. As for wild rice, i recently bought Trader Joe's pre-cooked wild rice and it is a huge timesaver. I used it in my own soup recipe if you're interested! http://doesabodygood.blogspot.com/2008/12/greektalian-wild-rice-soup.html
I know exactly what you mean about summer produce envy. Its only been a month or so since I had my last fresh tomato, but I'm so craving another...and god, it'll be June before I can get one. Thank goddess for sundried tomatoes for my winter salads!
Last season, I was one of those people that stockpiled fresh peas in my freezer, but this year, I used all the ones I tried to save before the produce season ended. Now I'm wishing I'd planned a little better.
This looks delicious! I will have to try making it soon!
Since I declared this week a soup-a-thon, this soup fit the bill perfectly for a nice hearty meal. I used 1 lb of black eyed peas *(soaked for an hour before) and added 3 carrots, a bullion cube instead of the soy sauce, and 1 large portabello instead of the baby ones.
Despite a cooking time closer to 1 hour, this soup was delicious!
I'm not sure if substituting soysauce would give it a different flavor or make it even better, but if anybody has an opinion on that, I would love to hear :)
Thanks Susan!
I made a version of this for my xmas dinner.. it was fantastic ;)
I just made this soup, and it was really watery :(
Maybe it's because I didn't mash up some of the beans, like you suggested? The flavor was good, but it seemed like it needed more substance. I think next time I will use more wild rice and maybe more mushrooms. My soup also didn't look like the picture at all because I couldn't find speckled butter beans, so I used the regular butter beans that come in a can, and the soup looked a lot lighter; I was thinking maybe it's because of the different beans. I think this soup might be really good with more rice and mushrooms and maybe chickpeas added?!
Ok, finally ready to make this! Quick question Susan, are those dried or fresh sage and thyme called for in your recipe? It isn't specified. I have both, I just want to get the portions right. Thanks.
Habanero, I used dried for both, but if you've got fresh, I think they would make it taste even better. Just use 2-3 times as much. Hope you enjoy it!
thanks very much for your help, Susan! I used some fresh thyme and sage for a pumpkin soup recipe this week and it was amazing. Really looking forward to trying your recipe.
I also made this version. It did not quite look like yours but it sure tasted good. All the best!
Post a Comment
Links to this post:
Create a Link
<< Home